Tinkerboard I2S DAC Compatibility: ApplePi DAC ?

DACs and Wireless Dongle Compatibility Thread. Post wether a particular device is working or not in Volumio

Ads helps Volumio remain Free and Open Source. Please consider donating to help us continue to serve you.

Tinkerboard I2S DAC Compatibility: ApplePi DAC ?

Postby Electric » Sun Dec 09 2018 18:21

Hi,

Does anyone know if volumio will recognize the ApplePi DAC on the Asus Tinkerboard? Is it just a case of updating the dacs.json file, adding ApplePi to the Tinkerboard array as described here > https://volumio.github.io/docs/I2S_DACs ... r_DAC.html ?

If it is then will volumio update the DAC JSON file in a future update to include more DACS on the tinker like the Applepi DAC. If not do you know if there is a plan for future work on compatibility to include DACs like the ApplePi on Tinkerboard with Volumio?

Thanks
Random avatar
Electric
Fresh off the boat
Fresh off the boat
 
Posts: 1
Joined: Sun Dec 09 2018 18:02

Ads helps Volumio remain Free and Open Source. Please consider donating to help us continue to serve you.


Tinkerboard I2S DAC Compatibility: ApplePi DAC ?

Postby orchardaudio » Mon Dec 10 2018 12:15

Please let me know if I can be of any help in getting ApplePi DAC supported on Tinkerboard.
User avatar
orchardaudio
Audiophile
Audiophile
 
Posts: 108
Joined: Thu Mar 22 2018 22:47
Location: Succasunna, NJ


Tinkerboard I2S DAC Compatibility: ApplePi DAC ?

Postby gkkpch » Sat Dec 22 2018 17:39

No, unfortunately it is not just a matter of volumio configuration, the DAC must be supported as well.
Asus is fairly open to the idea of integrating more DAC products, they do support a number of them already.

For the Apple PI it means, unless it uses existing DAC drivers, time and effort is required for kernel driver integration (we do not support out-of-tree).
We have done this with Asus kernel for tinkerboard before, so in principle we have the knowledge, but this is not the way we prefer it .

@orchardaudio: it is probably in your interest if you yourself could convince Asus to integrate the driver.
If you need contact names, please send me an email at volumio(at)bluewin.ch
I will introduce you. Once Asus is convinced, we will help with adding it to Volumio and the testing (DAC required as I don't have one)
Volumio OS Developer

You like my work? Then what about buying me a beer :)
User avatar
gkkpch
Moderator
 
Posts: 1869
Joined: Mon Dec 29 2014 22:38
Location: Bodensee, Switzerland


Tinkerboard I2S DAC Compatibility: ApplePi DAC ?

Postby orchardaudio » Mon Mar 04 2019 00:13

gkkpch wrote:@orchardaudio: it is probably in your interest if you yourself could convince Asus to integrate the driver.
If you need contact names, please send me an email at volumio(at)bluewin.ch
I will introduce you. Once Asus is convinced, we will help with adding it to Volumio and the testing (DAC required as I don't have one)


I just saw this. Please send me the contact info to get driver integrated for Tinkerboard.

Also do you know if they have the RPI-DAC driver integrated if that driver is integrated it is fully compatible with the ApplePi DAC and the soon to be released PecanPi DAC.
User avatar
orchardaudio
Audiophile
Audiophile
 
Posts: 108
Joined: Thu Mar 22 2018 22:47
Location: Succasunna, NJ


Tinkerboard I2S DAC Compatibility: ApplePi DAC ?

Postby orchardaudio » Wed Mar 06 2019 14:05

I have send a message to the Asus contact but have not heard back yet.
User avatar
orchardaudio
Audiophile
Audiophile
 
Posts: 108
Joined: Thu Mar 22 2018 22:47
Location: Succasunna, NJ


Tinkerboard I2S DAC Compatibility: ApplePi DAC ?

Postby orchardaudio » Sun Mar 10 2019 23:42

orchardaudio wrote:I have send a message to the Asus contact but have not heard back yet.


I got reply back from Asus, they are looking into it.
User avatar
orchardaudio
Audiophile
Audiophile
 
Posts: 108
Joined: Thu Mar 22 2018 22:47
Location: Succasunna, NJ


Tinkerboard I2S DAC Compatibility: ApplePi DAC ?

Postby orchardaudio » Fri Mar 15 2019 19:17

orchardaudio wrote:
orchardaudio wrote:I have send a message to the Asus contact but have not heard back yet.


I got reply back from Asus, they are looking into it.


Asus has finished porting the driver over to the tinkerboard system, I will work with them to test it. Looks like tinkerboard support is not far away for the PecanPi DAC.
User avatar
orchardaudio
Audiophile
Audiophile
 
Posts: 108
Joined: Thu Mar 22 2018 22:47
Location: Succasunna, NJ


Tinkerboard I2S DAC Compatibility: ApplePi DAC ?

Postby orchardaudio » Mon Mar 18 2019 23:26

orchardaudio wrote:
orchardaudio wrote:
orchardaudio wrote:I have send a message to the Asus contact but have not heard back yet.


I got reply back from Asus, they are looking into it.


Asus has finished porting the driver over to the tinkerboard system, I will work with them to test it. Looks like tinkerboard support is not far away for the PecanPi DAC.


I got a modified kernel from Asus, will be testing it out in the next week or so.

Edit:
At this time I do not have a completion date for tinkerboard support. It will be done and I will continue to post updates here.
Last edited by orchardaudio on Thu May 16 2019 23:38, edited 1 time in total.
User avatar
orchardaudio
Audiophile
Audiophile
 
Posts: 108
Joined: Thu Mar 22 2018 22:47
Location: Succasunna, NJ


Tinkerboard I2S DAC Compatibility: ApplePi DAC ?

Postby orchardaudio » Wed May 15 2019 00:19

I got an image from Asus which loads the overlay for the device and is able to play music files.

However there are still issues to be resolved.
  • When I have audacity play a 1kHz test file the output of the device is 977Hz instead of 1kHz, this works correctly on a Raspberry Pi.
  • THD+N is about 25dB worse when playing the 1kHz file compared to using Rapsberry Pi (this might be related to generating the wrong frequency).

I will continue to work with Asus to get all issues correct and be able to provide full support with Tinkerboard.
User avatar
orchardaudio
Audiophile
Audiophile
 
Posts: 108
Joined: Thu Mar 22 2018 22:47
Location: Succasunna, NJ


Tinkerboard I2S DAC Compatibility: ApplePi DAC ?

Postby orchardaudio » Sat May 09 2020 11:55

As of Tinker_Board-Debian-Stretch-V2.1.11-20200310, Asus has fixed the issue with the PecanPi DAC not working correctly.

I have verified proper operation using Audacios installed on the Tinker OS version listed above.

The TinkerOS image can be downloaded here:
https://dlcdnets.asus.com/pub/ASUS/mb/Embedded_IPC/TinkerBoard_S/Tinker_Board-Debian-Stretch-V2.1.11-20200310.zip?_ga=2.31686526.139520586.1588554034-1868854643.1584337493

To enable the PecanPi DAC in TinkerOS the following line needs to be added to the hw_intf.conf file.
Code: Select all
intf:dtoverlay=rpi-dac


For any of those who are interested please request that Volumio also add support.
User avatar
orchardaudio
Audiophile
Audiophile
 
Posts: 108
Joined: Thu Mar 22 2018 22:47
Location: Succasunna, NJ


Return to Compatibility List

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest